Thursday, October 14, 2004
My Early Thoughts on Tonight's Presidential Debate
Here. And here.
|posted by Jim on 1:34 AM|
Link
. . .
Wednesday, October 13, 2004
Colorado: We don't need no stinking registration deadlines
Colorado Secretary of State Donetta Davidson, citingher fearof "lawsuits claiming voters are being disenfranchised if they aren't allowed to vote" essentially voided the state's October 4th voter registration deadline.
"Wait till the media hears this," said Bob Balink, the El Paso County clerk. "Just by saying you signed up somewhere, someday, you're going to get to vote."
Even before Davidson's decision, vote fraud was likely to be a problem in Colorado:
Bill Compton, of the secretary of state's office, said that so far, several hundred questionable voter-application records have been turned over to the attorney general's office. That number may reach into the low thousands, he said, but it's hard to tell just how many are a problem because some county clerks are turning cases over to local district attorneys.
|posted by Jim on 6:39 PM|
Link
. . .
Maria Santiago: Language Rights Role Model
California's Argus newspaper carried a story criticizing translation services at Alameda County hospitals. The following excerpt is NOT a parody:
Maria Santiago of Mujeres Unidas y Activas, an advocacy group, said hospitals aren't providing adequate [translation] services.
"As Latina immigrant women, we demand better translation services and we will be watching to make sure the county complies," Santiago said through an interpreter (emphasis added).
Is this a great country or what? One does not have to learn English in order to drive, apply for welfare or, evidently, even to conduct a press conference.
Alas, Mujeres Unidas y Activas does not practice the linguistic diversity it demands of others. Their crisis counseling and support groups are available only in Spanish.
|posted by Jim on 1:56 AM|
Link
. . .
Meanwhile, Back in the USA
Education Week reports on how various cities deal with translation issues in their school systems:
The 750,000-student Los Angeles school system runs what many say is the most comprehensive school translation and interpretation service in the country. The district employs 79 full-time translators and interpreters and spends about $6.2 million a year for translation services.
That kind of money could be used to provide Berlitz English immersion classes for a lot of people and solve the problem for good, instead of creating yet another costly school system bureaucracy. But jobs are what the mandatory multilingualism crowd is interested in creating.
|posted by Jim on 1:20 AM|
Link
. . .
One India Textbook: 228 Pages; 29 Translation Errors
Accroding to the Ahmedabad Newsline: "In 29 instances, the meaning is different in Gujarati and English textbooks in the 228-page Social Science textbook." Example:
On page 166, the English text says: "Entire mankind works for our progress in such a way that the environment is degraded." What was the original? "The rapid progress mankind is making is also affecting environment."
How could such a thing happen? You guessed it. Not enough translators were hired to argue over the translations made by the other translators:
The translations have been done by Gujarati and English teachers and principals of various schools. The Board maintains that the manuscripts and translations were carefully reviewed by experts. However, the Board does not have academic peers as members who could give a critical opinion because they were never appointed. Neither did it have experienced editors to edit the texts and make sure translations did not stray from the original manuscripts.
Instead, the Board relied heavily on school teachers for reviewing. "Teachers and experts teaching at primary school level have reviewed and made some suggestions," says Board director Madhubhai Patel.
|posted by Jim on 1:09 AM|
Link
. . .
How Do You Say "Oops" in Arabic?
The trial of Afghan warlord Faryadi Sarwar Zardad ran into an immediate snag:
Television screens in the Old Bailey court clearly showed the first witness taking the oath on the Koran through an interpreter in Kabul, but when he started his evidence the interpretation became impossible to understand.
The case was adjourned while a second interpreter was called to the Old Bailey.
|posted by Jim on 12:47 AM|
Link
. . .
Friday, October 08, 2004
Bush-Kerry II
Much more interesting than Bush-Kerry I. The audience asked some great questions.
I told NRO tonight:
I was told time and time again in 1999 that a Texas Governor named George W. Bush was terrific in small groups. Now I see what they meant. Bush feeds off people's reaction like a good businessman/salesman. Kerry's twenty years in the Senate has made him most comfortable addressing an empty room, as any viewer of C-SPAN II has seen day after day.
Running commentary on National Review Online reminds that the audience to be concerned about were undecided voters. The polls will tell the final tale.
I was honored to take part in that running commentary tonight. Being that Kerry seems determined to seek Europe's approval for almost everything, the international law issue is hardly theoretical.
President Bush's views are not mine on issues of language. But he was the clear winner on issues like national security and taxes tonight.
|posted by Jim on 11:15 PM|
Link
. . .
France: English a World "Catastrophe" (Not a Parody)
Via James Taranto and Opinion Journal, Chirac warns of 'catastrophe' of world 'choked' by US values
HANOI, Oct 7 (AFP) - French President Jacques Chirac warned Thursday of a "catastrophe" for global diversity if the United States' cultural hegemony goes unchallenged.
Speaking at a French cultural centre in Hanoi ahead of Friday's opening of a summit of European and Asian leaders, Chirac said France was right to stand up for cultural and linguistic diversity.
The outspoken French president warned that the world's different cultures could be "choked" by US values.
This, he said, would lead to a "general world sub-culture" based around the English language, which would be "a real ecological catastrophe".
Citing Hollywood's stranglehold over the film industry as an example, Chirac stressed that only with government assistance could countries maintain their cultural heritage.
Vietnam is a former French colony, but only around 375,000 of its 81 million people speak French. English is considered by most people a far more valuable and practical second language, particularly among businessmen.
|posted by Jim on 8:00 PM|
Link
. . .
Wednesday, October 06, 2004
Be Afraid. Be Very Afraid.
Florida Supreme Court to hear appeal of provisional ballot case Oct. 13th. The line up, for and against, via the Miami Herald:
A coalition of unions, including the AFL-CIO, want the court to order election supervisors to count so-called provisional ballots regardless of where the voter turned them in.
Provisional ballots were created in the 2001 election reform law as a way to guarantee that voters whose names don't show up on the voting rolls, perhaps through error, could still vote on Election Day. If a check shows the voter is indeed eligible to vote, the ballot is counted.
Provisional ballots are on paper, just like absentee ballots.
But the caveat added by state legislators is that provisional ballots must be discarded if the voter didn't go to the right precinct. Lawyers for the unions say this violates Florida's Constitution, which requires only that voters cast their ballots in their home county. ...
Ron Labasky, who represents the Florida State Association of Supervisors of Elections, said nothing would stop special interest groups from telling voters to go out and demand a provisional ballot at any precinct instead of using the touch-screen voting machines used in 15 counties, including Broward and Miami-Dade.
"You could have tens of thousands of people going just down the street to vote," Labasky said. "The announcement could be, 'Don't worry about where you vote, just go vote.'"
|posted by Jim on 11:59 PM|
Link
. . .
Edwards, Kerry Invite Bush Counterattack on Language
Edwards opened a door again last night that Kerry-Edwards might ultimately regret if the Bush campaign simply chooses to take advantage of their mistakes:
With John Kerry as president of the United States, we are committed to immediately implementing all of the reforms suggested by the 9/11 Commission, so that we have the information we need to find terrorists and crush them before they hurt us.
Edwards was following Kerry's line of attack during the first debate last week, when Kerry complained about the FBI's Arabic translator shortage.
Their problem, and Team Bush's opportunity, is that both Kerry and Edwards are firmly on record as supporting policies that would only make the Arabic translator shortage worse.
Via Edwards' own Senate web site:
First, we need to stop differences in language and culture from interfering with good health care. I'd start with a National Medical Translation System. That means an effective, in-person translation system at every hospital in the biggest cities. For smaller cities and rural hospitals, we need a National Medical Translation Center—24 hours a day, 7 days a week, translators on call. To make this work, it'll take new incentives for doctors and nurses to become translators. At the end of the day, we will have solid medical translation services for the most vulnerable people in our society.
Note Edwards' lack of hesitation, in a speech given nearly two years after 9/11, about diverting limited Arabic translation resources from the FBI.
Still more documentation that, in a Kerry-Edwards Administration, political correctness would always triumph over national security can be found in my piece for NRO.
|posted by Jim on 3:26 PM|
Link
. . .
"My Baby Waves the Homer Hanky"
Twins beat Yankees 2-0.
|posted by Jim on 1:46 AM|
Link
. . .
Last Night's VP Debate
I primarily listened while working on an article, so I didn't see much regarding body language, save Edwards' stunned reaction to Cheney's Halliburton response:
The reason they keep trying to attack Halliburton is because they want to obscure their own record.
And Senator, frankly, you have a record in the Senate that's not very distinguished. You've missed 33 out of 36 meetings in the Judiciary Committee, almost 70 percent of the meetings of the Intelligence Committee.
You've missed a lot of key votes: on tax policy, on energy, on Medicare reform.
Your hometown newspaper has taken to calling you "Senator Gone."
You've got one of the worst attendance records in the United States Senate.
Now, in my capacity as vice president, I am the president of Senate, the presiding officer. I'm up in the Senate most Tuesdays when they're in session.
The first time I ever met you was when you walked on the stage tonight.
Not quite "You're no Jack Kennedy," but mighty close.
Dick Cheney sounded like a human being who actually answered the questions he was asked. Edwards sounded like he was simply reciting official campaign talking points. (The reverse of Bush - Kerry I last week.)
More later.
|posted by Jim on 1:06 AM|
Link
. . .
Monday, October 04, 2004
Florida Vote Fraud via ACORN?
Via the St. Petersburg Times
About a week after Jean Schuh got a phone call from ACORN, Charles Schuh received a letter from the Pinellas County Supervisor of Elections Office saying it had received his application form "as part of a voter registration drive" and that the form was sent in too late to allow him to vote in the Aug. 31 primary.
As Charles Schuh later put it, "They picked the wrong person to mess with."
A St. Petersburg attorney, Schuh served six years on the City Council and was the city's mayor from 1975-77. Schuh tried unsuccessfully to contact ACORN, and then took the letter and his voter registration card to the supervisor of elections.
He was shown the ACORN application form. Much of the information was wrong.
"And that was certainly not my signature," Schuh said. "I told them it was a blatant case of voter fraud and forgery, and someone ought to be taken to task for that."
Thankfully, ACORN activistists were slothful:
More than 2,500 Pinellas County residents and another 1,500 Hillsborough residents who thought they had registered for the Aug. 31 primary were notified they couldn't vote because the groups that helped them register failed to turn in their applications on time.
The majority of the late registration forms, including more than 2,100 in Pinellas, came from ACORN.
Similar voter registration problems involving ACORN were reported this year in Fort Lauderdale, New Mexico, Colorado, Ohio and Illinois.
What we won't know, until it is too late, is how many of the fake ACORN registratns will seek provisional ballots on Election Day?
|posted by Jim on 7:06 PM|
Link
. . .
Friday, October 01, 2004
Kerry Invokes FBI Translator Problems in First Debate
According to this transcript:
KERRY: The president just said the FBI had changed its culture. We just read on the front pages of America's papers that there are over 100,000 hours of tapes, unlistened to. On one of those tapes may be the enemy being right the next time.
And the test is not whether you're spending more money. The test is, are you doing everything possible to make America safe?
We didn't need that tax cut. America needed to be safe.
Kerry's solution to the FBI's translator shortage problem, as I explained at length in National Review Online this week, is to make the problem worse by imposing translation mandates for Arabic and other languages throughout the length and breadth of the United States.
The costs of such a mandate are unknown. Add to it all the personal injury lawsuits Kerry's running mate, John Edwards, and his fellow trial lawyers will bring against doctors for using a translator who spoke the wrong version of Arabic or Chinese and there will be precious little money left to provide tax cuts or make America safer.
One more thought about tax cuts. It seems that Kerry believes absolutely everything the government spends money on domestically is a vital necessity from which can be spared not a penny, but national defense is a luxury good which must be paid for by steep tax increases.
There were those who argued (and still do) that the United States should be spending lots more money on foreign aid and the United Nations instead of aggressively defending American interests. Had Gore been in office on September 11th, 2001, the question is not whether we would be fighting in Iraq, but rather would we be fighting anywhere, including Afghanistan?
The Clinton-Gore approach treated terrorist attacks, such as an unsuccessful attempt to blow up New York's World Trade Center, as a law enforcement/foreign aid issue. This approach has the advantage of being considerably cheaper and less likely to interfere with welfare spending at home. Its disadvantage is that it makes us appear to our enemies like craven cowards who seek to buy our way out of trouble.
Osama bin Laden thought America would fold up its tent in Israel, Saudi Arabia and elsewhere if his attacks on September 11th succeeded. How he got that idea remains worthy of discussion in this presidential race.
|posted by Jim on 8:27 PM|
Link
. . .
More on Bush's Talking Points Problem
Via National Review's Jay Nordlinger:
Bush said, "We're makin' progress" a hundred times — that seemed a little desperate. He also said "mixed messages" a hundred times — I was wishing that he would mix his message. He said, "It's hard work," or, "It's tough," a hundred times. In fact, Bush reminded me of Dan Quayle in the 1988 debate, when the Hoosier repeated a couple of talking points over and over, to some chuckles from the audience (if I recall correctly).
Staying on message is one thing; robotic repetition — when there are oceans of material available — is another. ...
Why did Bush keep requesting a special 30 seconds to say the same thing over and over?
|posted by Jim on 2:28 AM|
Link
. . .
The FBI's Translator Shortage
and Bill Clinton's contribution to it was the subject of my article yesterday in National Review Online.
The American Prospect's weblog, "Tapped" also ran an item yesterday on a key player in this scandal, former FBI translator Sibel Edmonds and linked to yet a third story in Bushwarsblog.
As Drudge would say, "developing."
|posted by Jim on 2:00 AM|
Link
. . .
Religion Not a GOP Monopoly
|posted by Jim on 1:59 AM|
Link
. . .
The Debates: Round 1 to Kerry
was my prediction to a colleague as we left a campaign fundraiser at 8:00 PM. Why? If the media gave Bush a win tonight, the Kerry campaign becomes as viable as one of Harold Stassen's nine presidential campaigns and the next 32 days become Dullsville.
After watching some of the debate on tape and listening to other parts on the car radio, I feel even more confident that the news for the next eight days will revolve around Kerry's "unexpectedly strong" showing tonight and new questions about Bush's reelection chances.
President Bush is not a classic debater. Rather, he is a "stay on message" speaker with an unfortunate inability to vary words of that message. Kerry is a classic debater who can take advantage of any opening.
In football terms, Bush is the Baltimore Ravens: impenetrable defense, barely adequate offense. Kerry is the Indianapolis Colts: vulnerable on defense but a good eye for the long pass.
A fair evaluation of tonight's debate would be a draw. I noticed no killer gaffes or objectionable body language. If you saw John Kerry debate in Iowa, you saw the same thing tonight.
From the post-debate commentary, Kerry backers thought their man won. Bush backers saw Kerry as a loser, by a margin either large or small. And the race continues.
|posted by Jim on 1:46 AM|
Link
. . .
|
. . .
|