Friday, January 24, 2003
MA Gov. Firm on English Immersion
From the January 24th Boston Globe:
The Globe reported yesterday that superintendents from 19 of Massachusetts' largest school systems wrote to Lieutenant Governor Kerry Healey asking that the administration support legislation to phase in English immersion over a three-year period. But yesterday, Romney press secretary Shawn Feddeman said the governor will fight all attempts to slow the implementation of English immersion, known on the ballot as Question 2. . . .
The 19 superintendents are part of the 22-member Urban Superintendents' Network, representing the Commonwealth's largest school systems. They prefer phasing in immersion, saying possible cuts in education funding will make it more difficult to train teachers.
How much "training" does it take for a schoolteacher to address a class in English?
|posted by Jim on 4:21 PM|
Link
. . .
Thursday, January 23, 2003
Survived "Donahue"
Transcript.
|posted by Jim on 5:59 PM|
Link
. . .
Tuesday, January 21, 2003
Translation Error Overturns Rape Conviction in CO
The sex-assault convictions of a man who moved to Colorado from Afghanistan 12 years ago were thrown out on January 16th be because the man had both an ineffective translator and a lawyer who didn't speak his client's language or research his culture. As the Denver Post explained:
"Defense counsel admitted that he had no knowledge of Afghan Dari or Middle Eastern languages," Judge Jose Marquez wrote. "He also admitted that he did not question the interpreter about his qualifications to interpret or defendant's ability to understand the interpreter."
Marquez said the lawyer admitted he didn't explain the U.S. justice system to Amini or research Amini's cultural background.
Amini had an Iranian Farsi- speaking interpreter who didn't speak Dari and had never been to Afghanistan or studied Afghan languages, the opinion said.
|posted by Jim on 12:55 AM|
Link
. . .
Oklahoma Official English Bill Introduced
House Bill 1020 would, if passed, make Oklahoma an English-first state. The bill is needed because:
Without at least a "rudimentary command" of the English language, residents of this state "are unable to make their voices heard in the legislative process, effectively exercise their right to vote, or fully understand the rights" guaranteed them by the Constitutions of Oklahoma and the United States. Persons unable to communicate in English also have more trouble finding gainful employment, obtaining affordable housing, acquiring health insurance, and securing for themselves and their families "the full benefits of American life ..."
|posted by Jim on 12:49 AM|
Link
. . .
Yes to One Language in the Workplace
Says a Seattle Times columnist.
|posted by Jim on 12:45 AM|
Link
. . .
Set Your VCR?
I, along with the owner of the AZ drive-in being sued by the EEOC and a cast of many others, will be doing the "Donahue" show on MSNBC.
The program is scheduled to air live at 8:00 p.m. on Tuesday, January 21st, and via tape at 11:00 p.m. (Eastern time).
You will note that the theme of this week's shows is "Angry White Males" which suggests what you might expect should you have time to tune in.
|posted by Jim on 12:41 AM|
Link
. . .
Monday, January 13, 2003
E.O. 13166 Repeal Bill Introduced
Congressman Peter King (R-NY introduced H.R. 300 in Congress last week. H.R. 300 would cut off all federal funds for enforcement of Clinton Executive Order 13166. (The legislation is identical to H.R. 969 in the last Congress.) As soon as my computer service gets its act together, I will update our legislative action center.
|posted by Jim on 3:41 PM|
Link
. . .
Refusing to Face Facts
Lots of fascinating discussion of Galileo today in National Review Online here and here, which reminded me of a tale told by David Sobel in Galileo's Daughter:
[U]niversity communities all over Europe honored the dictum of Aristotelian physics that objects of different weights fall at different speeds. A cannonball of ten pounds, for example, would be expected to fall ten times faster than a musket ball of only one pound so that if both were released together from the same summit, the cannonball would land before the musket ball had gotten more than one-tenth of the way to the ground.
Galileo's famously demonstrated otherwise by dropping a one-pound ball and a ten-pound ball from the Leaning Tower of Pisa.
[Galileo] did not succeed in swaying popular opinion down at the base of the Leaning Tower. The larger ball, being less susceptible to the effects of what Galileo recognized as air resistance, fell faster . . . The fact that it fell only fractionally faster gave Galileo scant advantage.
The "don't confuse me with facts" spirit of the folks at the base of the tower, who forgave Aristotle an error of 99% while rejecting Galileo for an error of less than one percent, is now part and parcel of the bilingual education establishment. Any student who learns three words of English after a decade in a bilingual education program is considered proof of the bilingual education's success everywhere, while a leap in English test scores statewide after bilingual education was repealed in California is considered proof of absolutely nothing at all.
|posted by Jim on 3:14 PM|
Link
. . .
Friday, January 10, 2003
WSJ Poll Results
"Should doctors be required to provide non-English-speaking patients with translators?"
Yes 234 (11%)
No 1815 (89%)
|posted by Jim on 10:33 AM|
Link
. . .
Thursday, January 09, 2003
Please Vote in This Online WSJ Poll
The Wall Street Journal has an article today on translation issues in medical offices ("For Ill Immigrants, Doctors' Orders Get Lost in Translation," Jan 9, 2003) which hints at the expense of Clinton Executive Order 13166.
Proof that there is no pleasing some people may be found in this complaint from a Bosnian woman regarding the accents of her interpreters:
Hataija Pehlic, a Bosnian woman of 50, suffers from depression. At St. Luke's Hospital in 2000, she was served by a succession of phone interpreters on a squawk box for two hours a day during a month of psychotherapy.
They spoke a common language, "but I felt really bad," Ms. Pehlic says through one of Ms. Brown's interpreters. "They had different accents" -- accents, that is, of Serbians and Croatians, the enemies who had killed her son and driven her husband to suicide during the Balkan bloodshed of the 1990s.
The Journal is conducting a poll:
"Should doctors be required to provide non-English-speaking patients with translators?"
You can vote here.
|posted by Jim on 5:31 PM|
Link
. . .
Wednesday, January 01, 2003
In Case You Missed It
"Help Still Wanted: Arabic Linguists", Washington Post, December 27, 2002 (free registration required):
Hiring linguists qualified in Middle Eastern languages has taken time, especially for jobs that carry national security clearances and require extensive background investigations.
The NSA [National Security Agency] has hired more than 800 people this year, but needs many more and hopes to bring in nearly twice as many in 2003. The FBI has hired nearly 300 linguists, but just over 100 of them are Arabic speakers. The bureau still has only a handful of agents who speak Arabic, probably fewer than 25, officials said.
"It takes 10 people in the front door to get one person out the other end," said Margaret Gulotta, head of language services for the FBI.
Gulotta said that 65 percent of applicants fail the bureau's language test; 20 percent can't pass a required polygraph and and 10 percent are eliminated for security reasons. All told, she said, the FBI has hired 286 translators and linguists since Sept. 11, 2001, in all languages, for both full-time and contract positions.
The NSA and the FBI can't find enough Arabic translators. Yet the Bush Administration has still not revoked Clinton Executive Order 13166. E.O. 13166 requires any recipient of federal funds, including a welfare office in Grand Forks, South Dakota, to provide translations into Arabic (or any other tongue) on the spot. So Grand Forks is required by the federal government to do what the FBI has admitted it is unable to do.
|posted by Jim on 5:13 AM|
Link
. . .
Happy New Year
|posted by Jim on 4:59 AM|
Link
. . .
|
. . .
|